Every Community has a Story to Tell

Facing History and Ourselves homepage

 

Back to Readings Home

History and Identity

Every community has a story to tell about how it came to be. That history is celebrated at community events, taught in textbooks, and memorialized in monuments and museums. This story about the founding of Los Angeles is taken from the Los Angeles County website:

When the Spanish occupation of California began in 1769, an exploratory expedition of more than 60 persons led by Gaspar de Portola moved north through the area now known as Los Angeles. They camped by a river where fertile soil and availability of water for irrigation impressed members of the party. Father Juan Crespi, who accompanied the group saw the location as having all the requirements for a large settlement. He named the river El Rio de Nuestra Señora la Reina de Los Angeles de Porciúncula, which means "The River of Our Lady the Queen of the Angels of Porciuncula."

In September 1771 Father Junipero Serra and a group of Spaniards founded the San Gabriel Mission as the center of the first "community" in an area inhabited by small bands of Gabrielino Indians.

Twelve years after Portola's trek, which began in San Diego and ended in Monterey, a company of settlers called "Los Pobladores" were recruited in the states of Sonora and Sinaloa in Mexico. Their mission, under the authority of Governor Felipe de Neve, was to establish pueblos in the name of the king of Spain.

On September 4, 1781, the Pobladores, a group of 12 families-46 men, women and children led by Captain Rivera y Moncada -established a community in the area discovered by Portola, and named it of El Pueblo de Nuestra Señora la Reina de Los Angeles de Porciúncula, after the nearby river. Over time, the area became known as the Ciudad de Los Angeles, "City of the Angels," and on April 4, 1850 became the City of Los Angeles.

California was ruled by Spain until 1822 when Mexico assumed jurisdiction. After a two-year period of hostilities with Mexico beginning in 1846, the area came under U.S. control. In 1848 the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo made California a United States territory.

The County of Los Angeles was established on February 18, 1850 as one of the 27 original counties, several months before California was admitted to the Union. It derived its name from the area known as Los Angeles, already a large community, and made it the designated "seat" of County government.

On April 1, 1850 the people of Los Angeles County asserted their newly won right of self-government and elected a three-man Court of Sessions as their first governing body. A total of 377 votes were cast in this election. In 1852 the Legislature dissolved the Court of Sessions and created a five-member Board of Supervisors. In 1913 the citizens of Los Angeles County approved a charter recommended by a board of freeholders which gave the County greater freedom to govern itself within the framework of state law.

The story told on the county website is part of the city's official history. Like all histories, it emphasizes some events, downplays others, and omits still others. In 1948, historian Carey McWilliams expressed concern about some details that are often left out of the story:

The city boasts of the Spanish origin of its first settlers. Here are their names: Pablo Rodriguez, Jose Variegas, Jose Moreno, Felix Villavicencio, Jose de Lara, Antonio Mesa, Basilio Rosas, Alejandro Rosas, Antonio Navarro, and Manuel Camero. All "Spanish" names, all good "Spaniards" except-Pablo Rodriguez who was an Indian; Jose Variegas, first [mayor] of the pueblo, also an Indian; Jose Moreno, a mulatto [of European and African descent]; Felix Villavicencio, a Spaniard married to an Indian; Jose de Lara, also married to an Indian; Antonio Navarro, a mestizo [of Spanish and Indian ancestry] with a mulatto wife; and Manuel Camero, a mulatto. The twelfth settler is merely listed as "a Chino" and was probably of Chinese descent. Thus of the original settlers of Our City the Queen of the Angels, their wives included, two were Spaniards; one mestizo; two were Negroes*; eight were mulattoes; and nine were Indians. None of that would matter …except that Mexicans are still not accepted as part of the community. (1)

Nearly 50 years later, Cecil L. Murray, the pastor of the Los Angeles's oldest African American church, reached a similar conclusion. He told a reporter, "Forty-six founders of Los Angeles, 42 of them were Native Americans and African Americans. Pico Boulevard is named after the last territorial governor of this territory-he was black. So we are part and parcel of this community." (2)


1 North from Mexico by Carey McWilliams. Greenwood Press, 1948, 1968, 36.
2 Quoted in "Cecil Murray; A Voice of Reason in Times of Trouble" by Robert Scheer. Los Angeles Times, May 3, 1992. Copyright 1992 Los Angeles Times.

 

CONNECTIONS

Working in small groups, tell the story of the founding of Los Angeles from a different perspective. What information would you like to highlight in your account? What might you add? Share your version with your classmates. What do all of the versions have in common? How do you account for differences? How important are those differences to our understanding of the story?

McWilliams writes that the additions he made to the story of Los Angeles's founding would not matter except that "Mexicans are still not accepted as part of the community." Nearly 50 years later, Murray makes the same point-not about Mexican Americans but about African Americans. Why does it matter who is included in the story and who is not? What does it mean to be left out of a story as important as the history of one's community?

What is the story of your community? Where do you go to learn that story?